Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangershell_tube_heat_exchanger
⚠ ⚠ Top risk: Cladding Disbonding · RPN 280 (Critical) — watch this one first at the equipment
Risk Board (all 28 · by RPN · top 6 highlighted urgent)
Shield: Safety = people/environment Production = production only
Technical mechanism/mitigation body in Chinese (red line: no fabricated MT; EN UI labels translated)
Cladding Disbonding
280 S8·O7·D5
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Production
Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC)
270 S9·O6·D5
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Production
Relief Valve Set-pressure Drift
224 S8·O7·D4
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Safety
Shell Crack
216 S9·O6·D4
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Safety
Fatigue Cracking
192 S8·O6·D4
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Production
Flow-induced Vibration Fatigue (Tube)
160 S8·O5·D4
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Production
Bolt Relaxation
160 S5·O8·D4
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every6months
Production
Corrosion Thinning
126 S7·O6·D3
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every12months
Production
Expanded Joint Leak
126 S6·O7·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every12months
Safety
Corrosion Thinning
126 S7·O6·D3
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every12months
Production
Tube Hole Enlargement
108 S6·O6·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Baffle Corrosion / Wear -> Loss of Tube Support
108 S6·O6·D3
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Inlet Line Blockage
108 S9·O4·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Safety
Tube Sheet Corrosion
105 S5·O7·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Channel Flange Leak
105 S5·O7·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Safety
Shell Internal Corrosion / Erosion
105 S7·O5·D3
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Bolt Corrosion
105 S7·O5·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Gasket Aging / Creep -> Leak
100 S5·O5·D4
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Safety
Partition Leak
96 S4·O8·D3
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Safety
Erosion
90 S6·O5·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Baffle Vibration Fatigue
84 S7·O4·D3
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Valve Seat Leak
84 S7·O4·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Safety
Improper Gasket Installation
72 S4·O6·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Safety
Blockage
72 S4·O6·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Re-inspect ≤every24months
Production
Sensor Drift
60 S5·O6·D2
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Interval by RBI
Production
Fouling/Plugging
54 S6·O3·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Interval by RBI
Production
Valve Internal Leak
54 S6·O3·D3
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Interval by RBI
Safety
Loose Wiring / Terminals
48 S4·O6·D2
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55%Interval by RBI
Production
28 Failure Modes
19 High/Critical
29 Standards
8 Real Accidents
Tap any failure mode to flip to its on-site guidance
Device-level standard/accident index (29 standards / 8 accidents)
Standards (29 de-duplicated)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesGB/T 11348GB/T 6075ISO 13372 — Condition monitoring and diagnostics of machines — VocabularyISO 13374 — Condition monitoring and diagnostics of machines — Data processing, communication and presentationISO 17359 — Condition monitoring and diagnostics of machines — General guidelinesAPI 581-2025GB/T 44692
Accident Lessons (8 de-duplicated)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 ↗ Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 ↗ Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 ↗ Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 ↗ Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 ↗ Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 ↗ ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 ↗ Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 ↗ Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸
FM Traceability Cards (28)
← Back to Risk Board Cladding Disbonding RPN 280 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
Improper welding procedure; hydrogen embrittlement; thermal cycling stress
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
Perform cladding UT inspection Check bonding interface for disbondment Control thermal-cycle rate RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) RPN 270 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
Residual or operating stress; corrosive medium (Cl-, H2S); susceptible material (austenitic stainless steel)
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
Periodic NDT (e.g., PT, UT) Monitor corrosion-environment parameters (e.g., chloride concentration, pH) Check stress-relief status RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Relief Valve Set-pressure Drift RPN 224 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
Relief valve set-pressure drift: long-term spring stress creep/fatigue, loose setting nut, or seat fouling make actual opening pressure deviate from set point. Consequence: (1) too high -> valve fails to lift when needed, equipment overpressure (safety/integrity risk); (2) too low -> spurious lift in normal operation (production loss, media release). Progressive degradation; managed by periodic set-pressure verification (API 510 / GB-T 44692 class).
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
Annual online set-pressure verification Inspect spring appearance and dimensions every half-year Record actuation count after each action and analyze trend RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Shell Crack RPN 216 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
焊接缺陷或热处理不当产生残余应力;频繁的温度波动引起热疲劳;应力腐蚀开裂(如氯化物应力腐蚀)
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每12个月进行渗透检测和超声波检测,重点检查焊缝和应力区 安装声发射监测系统,实时检测裂纹扩展 发现裂纹立即停机评估并修复 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Fatigue Cracking RPN 192 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
频繁的启停或温度波动;膨胀节设计不当(如波数不足);安装偏差导致附加应力
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Flow-induced Vibration Fatigue (Tube) RPN 160 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
Excessive velocity; excessive support span; tube natural frequency coupled with excitation frequency
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
Monitor tube-bundle vibration acceleration Inspect support-plate wear Adjust flow velocity or add anti-vibration rods RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (27)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 11348GB/T 6075GB/T 7826-2012ISO 13372 — Condition monitoring and diagnostics of machines — VocabularyISO 13374 — Condition monitoring and diagnostics of machines — Data processing, communication and presentationISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentISO 17359 — Condition monitoring and diagnostics of machines — General guidelinesSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Bolt Relaxation RPN 160 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
Operating temperature above bolt creep temperature; initial preload too low/high; low bolt creep strength
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every6months
Mitigation (What to Do)
Check bolt preload Replace aged bolts Re-tighten and lock RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Corrosion Thinning RPN 126 · High
Failure Mechanism
介质腐蚀性强;流速过高加速腐蚀;材料耐蚀性不足
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every12months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每年进行壁厚测量(超声测厚) 若壁厚减薄超过10%则计划更换 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (23)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionAPI 581-2025GB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Expanded Joint Leak RPN 126 · High
Failure Mechanism
Improper expansion; large temperature swing; corrosive medium attacking expansion face
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every12months
Mitigation (What to Do)
Periodic expansion-joint leak test Check expansion residual stress Replace gasket RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Corrosion Thinning RPN 126 · High
Failure Mechanism
壳程或管程流体含腐蚀性介质;膨胀节材料耐蚀性不足;防腐涂层失效或未涂覆
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every12months
Mitigation (What to Do)
RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (23)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionAPI 581-2025GB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Tube Hole Enlargement RPN 108 · High
Failure Mechanism
介质腐蚀;多次胀接;管孔加工精度不足
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
超声波测厚检查管孔壁厚 检查胀接处密封性 必要时重新胀接或堵管 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (23)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionAPI 581-2025GB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Baffle Corrosion / Wear -> Loss of Tube Support RPN 108 · High
Failure Mechanism
壳程流体含固体颗粒或腐蚀性介质;流体流速过高或流向不均;折流板材料耐蚀性不足
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每12个月抽芯检查折流板厚度和完整性 当折流板减薄超过50%时,更换折流板 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Inlet Line Blockage RPN 108 · Critical
Failure Mechanism
介质含固体杂质;介质易结垢;管道设计不合理导致死角
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每3个月检查入口管压差 每6个月进行内窥镜检查 安装压差报警装置 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Tube Sheet Corrosion RPN 105 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
介质腐蚀性强;管板材料耐蚀性差;缝隙腐蚀
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (24)
API 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 580 — Risk-Based InspectionAPI 581-2025GB/T 44692GB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Channel Flange Leak RPN 105 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
垫片失效;螺栓预紧力不足;法兰面腐蚀
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Shell Internal Corrosion / Erosion RPN 105 · High
Failure Mechanism
壳程流体含有腐蚀性成分(如H2S、CO2、Cl-);流体流速过高或存在湍流、涡流;壳体材料选型不当或缺乏防腐涂层
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每6个月进行超声波测厚,重点检查入口和底部 当壁厚减薄至设计最小值的85%时,安排修复或更换 RCM Strategy
RTF Design Modification / Inspection Task
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Bolt Corrosion RPN 105 · High
Failure Mechanism
环境含腐蚀性介质(如湿H2S、氯化物);螺栓材料耐蚀性不足;防腐涂层失效
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每6个月进行目视检查,记录腐蚀情况 每2年进行超声波测厚,测量螺栓剩余直径 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Gasket Aging / Creep -> Leak RPN 100 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
垫片材料与介质不兼容;运行温度超过垫片额定温度;垫片长期受压蠕变
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每40000小时或5年更换垫片 每次检修时检查垫片压缩回弹率 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Partition Leak RPN 96 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
密封垫片老化;隔板腐蚀;安装偏差
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
检查隔板密封面腐蚀情况 Replace gasket 重新紧固螺栓 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Baffle Vibration Fatigue RPN 84 · High
Failure Mechanism
壳程流体流速过高或脉动;折流板间距过大或厚度不足;管束与折流板间隙过大导致冲击
How to Detect
Online monitoring · Detection rate 80% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每3个月进行振动监测,安装加速度传感器 当振动幅值超过阈值时,调整流速或增加支撑 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Valve Seat Leak RPN 84 · High
Failure Mechanism
密封面腐蚀或磨损;密封面有异物;阀座材料不当
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
每日进行泄漏检测(听音、气泡或气体检测) 每季度进行密封性试验 每次检修检查密封面状态 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Improper Gasket Installation RPN 72 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
安装人员操作不规范;法兰面有划痕或腐蚀;垫片型号或尺寸错误
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Re-inspect ≤every24months
Mitigation (What to Do)
安装后立即进行气密试验 发现泄漏后重新安装并检查法兰面 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Sensor Drift RPN 60 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
敏感元件老化;传感器污染;环境温度变化
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Interval by RBI
Mitigation (What to Do)
Zero and span calibration every 6 months Compare redundant-sensor readings every 3 months RCM Strategy
PM Scheduled (Proactive) Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Fouling/Plugging RPN 54 · High
Failure Mechanism
水质硬度高或含悬浮物;流速过低导致沉积;介质易结焦或聚合
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Interval by RBI
Mitigation (What to Do)
每月监测换热器压差和出口温度 若压差升高或传热效率下降则进行化学清洗或机械清理 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Valve Internal Leak RPN 54 · High
Failure Mechanism
密封面磨损或腐蚀;密封面有异物;阀杆操作不当导致密封面损伤
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Interval by RBI
Mitigation (What to Do)
每月监测阀门前后压差 每季度进行内漏测试(如温度检测) 每年检修阀门密封面 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗
← Back to Risk Board Loose Wiring / Terminals RPN 48 · Medium
Failure Mechanism
振动导致松动;接线端子腐蚀;安装时未拧紧
How to Detect
Inspection/offline · Detection rate 55% ;Interval by RBI
Mitigation (What to Do)
每6个月检查并紧固所有接线端子 使用扭矩扳手按规范力矩紧固 红外热成像检测异常温升 RCM Strategy
CBM On-Condition Maintenance
Interval: High risk 1-3 mo / Medium 6-12 mo / Low risk at turnaround (by API 581 RBI risk ranking)
Engineering-inferred (not measured history); confirm with equipment owner before execution
Standards (22)
API 580 — Risk-Based InspectionGB/T 7826-2012ISO 14224:2016 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Collection and exchange of reliability and maintenance data for equipmentSAE JA1011_202411 — Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance ProcessesGB/T 27921-2011GB/T 36894-2018GB/T 44958-2024GB/T 4888-2008GB/T 29639-2020AQ/T 3034-2022API 581 — Risk-Based Inspection MethodologyAPI 510 — Pressure Vessel Inspection CodeAPI 570 — Piping Inspection CodeAPI 571 — Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining IndustryAPI 579-1/ASME FFS-1 — Fitness-For-ServiceAPI 754 — Process Safety Performance IndicatorsAPI 576 — Inspection of Pressure-Relieving DevicesAPI 689 — Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance DataAPI 755 — Human FactorsISO 20815:2018 — Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries — Production assurance and reliabilityIEC 61511:2016 — Functional safety — Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sectorISO 31000:2018 — Risk management — GuidelinesLessons Learned (8)
2008-06-I-TX csb 2008 Fatalities 1 · Injuries 6 · Safety/Environmental Goodyear 换热器破裂与氨泄漏(休斯顿) Root cause: 维护完成后的超压保护(泄压阀/安全系统)未有效复位或设定不足,换热器异常超压破裂,氨释放致 1 死 6 伤 Official source ↗ 2016-02-I-MS csb 2016 Safety/Operational Enterprise Pascagoula 气体厂换热器热疲劳破裂(帕斯卡古拉) Root cause: BAHX 热疲劳开裂;服役寿命与热循环评估不足,PHA 未识别低温热疲劳失效 Official source ↗ 2012-03-I-CA csb 2012 Safety/Environmental Chevron Richmond Refinery Piping Leak and Fire Root cause: High-temperature sulfidation corrosion rate underestimated + insufficient wall-thickness monitoring. Official source ↗ 2010-05-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes Refinery Heat Exchanger Rupture Root cause: Shell-side corrosion of heat exchanger not detected + design did not address shell-side integrity. Official source ↗ 2013-02-I-LA csb 2013 Fatalities 2 · Injuries 167 · Safety Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Explosion Root cause: Reboiler level loss of control + inadequate overpressure protection + hot-gas bypass valve mistakenly opened. Official source ↗ 2016-03-I-LA csb 2016 Injuries 4 · Safety ExxonMobil Baton Rouge Refinery Explosion Root cause: Heat-exchanger thermal fatigue + flange seal failure + insufficient pressure relief. Official source ↗ 2006-1-I-TX csb 2005 Injuries 2 · Safety Formosa Plastics Olefins Unit Release Root cause: Heat-exchanger nozzle weld defect + delayed leak detection. Official source ↗ 2010-08-I-WA csb 2010 Fatalities 7 · Safety Tesoro Anacortes 炼厂换热器高温氢腐蚀破裂爆炸 Root cause: 换热器碳钢壳体长期高温氢环境服役发生 HTHA 劣化,行业标准(API RP 941 Nelson 曲线)不足以预防;破裂爆炸致 7 名员工死亡 Official source ↗